|
|
General Quarters (3rd edition)Author: LL Gill & Norm Harm
Published: 2006, Old Dominion Gameworks Price: $40 loose leaf Length: 193 pgs Genre: Naval, World War II era Scale: Fleet actions |
|
Steve's
|
"A near perfect blend of simulation and playability, GQ3 is simply the best WW2 naval rule set out there."
Presentation: 7 of 10
Playability: 10 of 10 Mechanics: 9 of 10 Historical Flavor: 10 of 10 Support: 10 of 10 |
|
Steve's
|
"If a better set of WW2 naval rules comes along, I'll never know about it, because I stopped looking after I found GQ3."
Presentation: 7 of 10
Playability: 8 of 10 Mechanics: 8 of 10 Historical Flavor: 9 of 10 Support: 10 of 10 |
|
Tom's
|
"GQ3 is the best of all worlds in 20th century naval gaming in terms of complexity and historical flavor."
Presentation: 6 of 10
Playability: 8 of 10 Mechanics: 8 of 10 Historical Flavor: 9 of 10 Support: 10 of 10 |
|
Greg's Score80 |
"Don't let the intimidating, complex fire tables fool you--GQ3 is fast playing and easy to learn."
Presentation: 6 of 10
Playability: 9 of 10 Mechanics: 7 of 10 Historical Flavor: 8 of 10 Support: 10 of 10 |
|
Josh's Score79 |
"While not an experienced master of naval wargaming rules, I always enjoy GQ3 battles. It's easy to pick up and command some ships after being away from the rule set for a year."
Presentation: 3 of 10
Playability: 9 of 10 Mechanics: 8 of 10 Historical Flavor: 9 of 10 Support: 7 of 10 |
|
Chal's Score79 |
"GQ3 does a great job crunching data and details into a highly playable and enjoyable system."
Presentation: 7 of 10
Playability: 8 of 10 Mechanics: 8 of 10 Historical Flavor: 9 of 10 Support: 6 of 10 |
|
Tony's
|
"I own a variety of naval rules, including the General Quarters predecessors. This is THE set of rules for early 20th century naval combat."
Presentation: 7 of 10
Playability: 7 of 10 Mechanics: 8 of 10 Historical Flavor: 8 of 10 Support: 9 of 10 |